Pleasant Lake Inn Restaurant

4.7 ( 131 reviews )
Checking... See Hours
5083 NY-29A, Stratford, NY 13470, United States
+1 315-429-3377
Pleasant Lake Inn Restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere paired with a menu that delights the senses. Located in Stratford, New York, this American restaurant has garnered rave reviews, showcasing a commitment to quality and flavor. Diners rave about the generous portions and delectable rotating specials, such as the beef stew and chicken fajitas, each crafted with fresh ingredients and expert seasoning. Many guests appreciate the stellar service provided by the friendly staff. Reviewers like Masyat Tomory and Noah praise the juicy burgers and massive NY strip steak, noting that each dish is prepared to near perfection. Desserts, particularly the berry shortcake and pumpkin cheesecake, have become crowd favorites, making it hard to resist saving room for a sweet ending. Olev Viro highlights the delicious dips and generous servings, while Devon Percival captures the essence of the establishment—great atmosphere and a diverse menu. Whether you prefer a cozy dinner among friends or a special occasion meal, Pleasant Lake Inn Restaurant stands out as a memorable dining experience that invites you to return time and again.

Amenities and More

  • 0
    • Kid-friendly
    • 1

Reviews For Pleasant Lake Inn Restaurant

mashyat tomory
May 26,2025
Love the food. It was fresh and taste to come back for. We went as a group of 6, all the burgers were juicy, tender and perfectly charred. Portions are huge. The servers were amazing and friendly. Totally recommend the berry short cake for dessert, it comes with fresh house made ice cream and whipped cream.
Noah
Mar 25,2025
My wife and I got the specials and it was a great choice! The steak was huge and juicy. The sides were amazing. Everything tasted fresh, seasoned, and came at a solid pace. The pumpkin cheesecake WAS AWESOME. The woman who served us was excellent. Highly recommended.
Lisa Marie
Mar 23,2025
Absolutely wonderful food and service. All the dips are gluten-free and come with delicious chips safe for the entire family. Staff was friendly, professional,and juggled a slammed restaurant efficiently. Try to save room for dessert!
Olev Viro
Mar 18,2025
Three of us were welcomed and given first rate service and hospitality by Nate and Amy! Amys warm dip was delicious - we had to stop eating it to leave room for dinner. The burger and schnitzel were very good, the fish (Thursdays only) lightly breaded and flaky, worth the trip! Portions were very generous and atmosphere warm and relaxed. We look forward to returning!
Devon Percival
Mar 11,2025
Great atmosphere excellent service and love the variety of foods.
Debbie Tarantino
Mar 2,2025
If you are in the area, this place is a MUST!! Food was incredible... From Amy's delicious dips to Nate's culinary genius. You cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. Equally impressive though is how warm and inviting everyone is!! Amy, the entire staff and even fellow patrons welcome you the minute you walk in!! This place is MAGIC!
John King
Feb 20,2025
OMG! This place is an Adirondack Gem.... What a wonderful place to share with family. All of the food (Especially the Specials) show off freshness and the caring touch of the chef. I am guessing, but I believe that the owners are on the floor and in the kitchen making magic all around. We had dinner here for my daughters birthday while on vacation and they made it special. Thank you Amy!
Jeannine Reid
Feb 10,2025
after walking out of the Nick Stoner restaurant we came across the Lake Pleasant Inn, fine dining restaurant and they opened their arms and welcomed us seated us right away gave us complementary drinks for the inconvenience that we had which was nothing and served us the most wonderful food from the most wonderful servers and restaurant owners that there are. we will be making a return visit to this establishment we come from Rome, New York so it's quite a distance for us to drive but we were so pleasantly surprised with our dinners. They were fabulous. Everything was delicious. The seafood platters were just grand. The stuffed haddock was wonderful. We had a wonderful time. It was so cozy and welcoming that we definitely will be back a five star all the way around

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Las Fajitas Bentonville #2 - Mexican Restaurant
(633 review)
Las Fajitas Bentonville #2 - Mexican Restaurant
  • 2003 SW Regional Airport Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 479-657-2594
The Hidden Gem Cafe
(634 review)
The Hidden Gem Cafe
  • The Bents Green, Ringinglow Rd, Sheffield S11 7TB, United Kingdom
Cafe
+44 114 262 0094
Pita Mediterranean Grill
(548 review)
Pita Mediterranean Grill
  • 3964 Goodman Rd E # 101, Southaven, MS 38672, United States
Restaurant
+1 662-420-7939
Bridge Street Pizza
(202 review)
Bridge Street Pizza
  • 16 E Bridge St, Dublin, OH 43017, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 614-761-3169
Mancino's Grinders & Pizza
(410 review)
Mancino's Grinders & Pizza
  • 10874 Isabelle Dr, New Haven, IN 46774, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 260-748-4103
Frank From Philly & Andrea Pizza
(1376 review)
Frank From Philly & Andrea Pizza
  • 1235 4th St SE, Minneapolis, MN 55414, United States
pizza restaurant
+1 612-208-1973
P.J. Whelihan's Pub Restaurant - Malvern
(2043 review)
P.J. Whelihan's Pub Restaurant - Malvern
  • 12 General Warren Blvd, Malvern, PA 19355, United States
Bar & grill
+1 610-981-4600
Shoku Sushi & Grill
(137 review)
Shoku Sushi & Grill
  • 205 Spring Creek Common SW #105, Calgary, AB T3H 6H4, Canada
restaurant
+1 403-930-7888
Radio Road Bistro
(594 review)
Radio Road Bistro
  • 978 Radio Rd, Little Egg Harbor Township, NJ 08087, United States
Breakfast restaurant
+1 609-294-9670
Bodean's Tower Hill
(3951 review)
Bodean's Tower Hill
  • 16 Byward St, London EC3R 5BA, United Kingdom
Barbecue restaurant
+44 20 7488 3883